Questions about privacy, data sharing and oversight dominated a discussion Tuesday at the Kern County Board of Supervisors as officials reviewed the Kern County Sheriff’s Office use of Flock cameras, a technology that captures vehicle images and makes license plate information searchable. Flock cameras, also known as automatic license plate readers, are used by the sheriff’s office to help identify criminal activity, locate stolen vehicles and support missing person investigations. “The primary use is to identify criminal activity, stolen automobiles and support missing person investigations” Kern County Sheriff's Office Chief Deputy David Kessler said.
The sheriff’s office currently has 66 Flock cameras and two portable cameras, along with 17 ALPR-equipped Axon cameras on department vehicles. During public comment, community members raised concerns about how the information is stored and who can access it, including the ability for other agencies to search the data. “300 agencies across CA can search that data,” Jason Cosper said. “Its ease of use is also what makes it easy to abuse” The sheriff’s office said data is kept for 30 days.
Deputies must provide a case number and investigative reason to search the system, and all searches are logged and subject to random audits. Sheriff’s officials also said the cameras cannot see inside vehicles, and that unauthorized data searches could lead to discipline. “Most likely termination, depending on the severity of it,” Kessler said. Kessler also described cases where the technology has helped investigators, including a shooting investigation. “This year there was a drive-by shooting where detectives were able to locate and identify the shooter within 20 minutes of receiving the video from a witness,” Kessler said.
Officials said Flock is only one part of an investigation and that other evidence is needed before an arrest. However, the sheriff’s office does not currently track how many cases the system has helped solve, after losing that ability during a records-management system change. One speaker criticized the limited number of examples provided. “In the over 600 thousand views in one month, you guys have three examples of it being used to solve crimes,” a public commenter said. Another community member called for shorter data retention, limiting data sharing to local agencies and an independent audit.
The sheriff’s office said it only shares data with California law enforcement agencies, not private companies, federal authorities or immigration authorities.